Why Gareth Bale is a Tottenham icon: His legacy explained

Gareth Bale is a Tottenham icon because he turned a club on the verge of Champions League qualification into a side that could beat Inter Milan 3-1 at the San Siro. That is not nostalgia talking. Bale won the Premier League Player of the Year award twice, in 2010/11 and 2012/13. In his final two seasons at Spurs he scored 42 goals from midfield, a total that still looks like a typo. The question is not whether Bale belongs in the same conversation as Jimmy Greaves or Glenn Hoddle. The question is whether any Tottenham player has ever carried a team harder over a sustained stretch.

The transformation from left-back to talisman

Bale arrived at Tottenham Hotspur in 2007 from Southampton as a 17-year-old left-back. His early Premier League appearances were not promising. He played in 24 matches for Spurs before he was part of a winning side. That run of 24 winless appearances became a running joke, but it masked something important. The talent was visible in flashes, even if the results were not.

Harry Redknapp pushed Bale further forward, first to left midfield, then to the left wing. The physical tools were absurd. Bale could run past defenders on either side, shoot with power from distance, and deliver crosses that required no second touch. Once he stopped worrying about defensive responsibilities, his numbers exploded.

In 2009/10 he scored 3 goals and added 5 assists in 23 league appearances. The next season, 2010/11, he scored 11 goals and made 7 assists. That was the season he won his first Premier League Player of the Year award. The leap was not gradual. It was a step change.

The mechanism: pace, power, and the outside-of-the-foot finish

Bale's game was built on three things. First, his acceleration over the first five yards was elite. Defenders knew he would go down the outside, and they still could not stop him. Second, he could shoot with his laces from 25 yards with the ball swerving away from the goalkeeper. That shot became his signature. Third, he had an unusual ability to finish with the outside of his left foot, bending the ball around the goalkeeper from tight angles.

What made him different from other fast wingers was his durability under physical pressure. Premier League defenders tried to kick him. They tried to double up. They tried to foul him early. Bale kept getting up. In 2012/13 he was fouled 85 times in the league, the third-highest total that season, and still scored 21 goals.

History: the 2012/13 peak

The 2012/13 season was Bale's masterpiece. He scored 21 goals in 33 league appearances for a Tottenham side that finished fifth. Only Robin van Persie (26) and Luis Suarez (23) scored more. Bale did it from midfield, often from the left, sometimes through the middle, and occasionally from positions that did not exist on a tactics board.

He scored a hat-trick against Aston Villa. He scored a 30-yard winner against West Ham. He scored a free kick at the Emirates that looked like it was still rising when it hit the net. That season he won the Premier League Player of the Year award, the Football Writers' Association Footballer of the Year, and the PFA Players' Player of the Year. He was the first player since Cristiano Ronaldo in 2007/08 to win all three.

Tottenham finished fifth that season, one point behind Arsenal. Without Bale's 21 goals, they would have been closer to 10th. That is not hyperbole. The gap between Bale and the next highest scorer in the squad was 16 goals.

Edge cases and common confusions

A common argument is that Bale was a one-season wonder. That is false. He won the Premier League Player of the Year award twice, separated by two seasons. Between 2010/11 and 2012/13 he scored 42 league goals. Only van Persie (56) and Wayne Rooney (44) scored more among midfielders and forwards in that span.

Another confusion is that Bale was a winger in the traditional sense. He was not. He started as a left-back, then became a left winger who cut inside, and by 2012/13 he was effectively a free-roaming second striker. Andre Villas-Boas gave him license to drift central, and Bale responded by shooting from anywhere inside 35 yards. He took 142 shots in 2012/13, the most in the league. That was not selfishness. That was the game plan.

Some argue that Bale's legacy at Tottenham is diminished because he left for Real Madrid in 2013 for a world-record fee. That misses the point. He left because he had outgrown the league. Tottenham finished fifth in his final season. Real Madrid had just won La Liga. The move was the logical endpoint of his development. It does not erase what he did at Spurs.

The Champions League nights

The defining moment of Bale's Spurs career was not a league match. It was the 2010/11 Champions League group stage. Tottenham faced Inter Milan at the San Siro. Inter were the reigning European champions. Bale scored a hat-trick. Tottenham lost 4-3, but the performance announced Bale as a player who could dominate on the biggest stage.

Two weeks later, in the return leg at White Hart Lane, Bale destroyed Maicon, widely considered the best right-back in the world at the time. Bale scored twice and assisted another in a 3-1 win. Maicon was substituted at half-time. That night, Bale went from a promising Premier League player to a global name.

Key takeaways

• Gareth Bale won the Premier League Player of the Year award twice, in 2010/11 and 2012/13, making him one of only four players to win it multiple times.
• He scored 42 league goals in his final two seasons at Tottenham, a total unmatched by any other midfielder in the league during that period.
• Bale's hat-trick against Inter Milan at the San Siro in 2010 remains the defining European performance by a Spurs player in the modern era.
• He was the first player since Cristiano Ronaldo to win the PFA Player of the Year, FWA Footballer of the Year, and Premier League Player of the Year in the same season.
• Tottenham finished fifth in 2012/13; without Bale's 21 goals, they would have been a mid-table side.

FAQ

Did Gareth Bale win a trophy at Tottenham?

No. Bale's six seasons at Tottenham did not produce a trophy. Spurs finished in the top five in four of his six seasons but never won the league, FA Cup, or League Cup. That is the main criticism of his time at the club, though it says more about the squad around him than his individual performance.

Why did Bale leave Tottenham?

Real Madrid signed Bale in September 2013 for a world-record fee of £85.1 million. Bale had just won the Premier League Player of the Year award and wanted to compete for the Champions League. He won four Champions League titles at Real Madrid.

Is Bale the best Tottenham player ever?

That depends on how you measure it. Jimmy Greaves scored 266 goals for Spurs. Glenn Hoddle was a more complete technical player. But in terms of carrying a team to results it had no right to achieve, Bale is in the conversation. No Spurs player has ever won the Premier League Player of the Year award twice.

What position did Bale play at Tottenham?

He started as a left-back, then moved to left midfield, then left wing, and finally a free role behind the striker. By his final season he was essentially a second striker with no defensive responsibilities.

Learn more about Gareth Bale | Tottenham Hotspur history | Premier League legends